Driver Behavior Evaluation of Variable Speed Limits and a Conceptual Framework for Optimal VSL Location Identification PDF Download
Are you looking for read ebook online? Search for your book and save it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. Download Driver Behavior Evaluation of Variable Speed Limits and a Conceptual Framework for Optimal VSL Location Identification PDF full book. Access full book title Driver Behavior Evaluation of Variable Speed Limits and a Conceptual Framework for Optimal VSL Location Identification by Curt P. Harrington. Download full books in PDF and EPUB format.
Author: Curt P. Harrington
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category :
Languages : en
Pages : 77
Get Book Here
Book Description
Static speed limits are the norm across the world's roadway networks. However, advances in technology and increased applications in intelligent transportation systems (ITS) provide a mechanism for upgrading traditional speed limits into an active traffic management system. More specifically, variable speed limits (VSLs) can be used in high crash severity locations and in real-time congestion and weather events to increase traffic safety and operations. Much of the available literature on VSLs focuses upon crash prediction algorithms for VSLs, simulations, and effectiveness of real-world VSL implementations. One noticeable gap in the existing literature is related to driver compliance under varied configurations of alerting drivers of the variable speeds. An additional gap in literature is related to existence of a conceptual framework for identifying optimal corridors for potential VSL implementation. Within this thesis drivers' willingness to comply with VSLs was investigated via focus groups and static surveys during the experimental process. Connections are made between driver speed choice and type of speed limit condition including uniform speed vi limit (USL) versus VSL, overhead mount versus side mount, presence of an explanatory message, and the numerical speed limit value. An analysis of the survey results was completed to isolate critical factors in VSL compliance. Opinions and perspectives on VSLs are derived through the focus group sessions Lastly, a case study approach is presented in which a region is chosen, and implementation metrics are analyzed on the major roadway networks using a GIS platform to create a composite ranking system for potential optimal VSL corridors. The study aims to be used as a foundation to justify use of certain types of VSLs in addition to creating a conceptual framework for VSL implementation zone identification.
Author: Curt P. Harrington
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category :
Languages : en
Pages : 77
Get Book Here
Book Description
Static speed limits are the norm across the world's roadway networks. However, advances in technology and increased applications in intelligent transportation systems (ITS) provide a mechanism for upgrading traditional speed limits into an active traffic management system. More specifically, variable speed limits (VSLs) can be used in high crash severity locations and in real-time congestion and weather events to increase traffic safety and operations. Much of the available literature on VSLs focuses upon crash prediction algorithms for VSLs, simulations, and effectiveness of real-world VSL implementations. One noticeable gap in the existing literature is related to driver compliance under varied configurations of alerting drivers of the variable speeds. An additional gap in literature is related to existence of a conceptual framework for identifying optimal corridors for potential VSL implementation. Within this thesis drivers' willingness to comply with VSLs was investigated via focus groups and static surveys during the experimental process. Connections are made between driver speed choice and type of speed limit condition including uniform speed vi limit (USL) versus VSL, overhead mount versus side mount, presence of an explanatory message, and the numerical speed limit value. An analysis of the survey results was completed to isolate critical factors in VSL compliance. Opinions and perspectives on VSLs are derived through the focus group sessions Lastly, a case study approach is presented in which a region is chosen, and implementation metrics are analyzed on the major roadway networks using a GIS platform to create a composite ranking system for potential optimal VSL corridors. The study aims to be used as a foundation to justify use of certain types of VSLs in addition to creating a conceptual framework for VSL implementation zone identification.
Author: Nicholas J. Fudala
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Road work zones
Languages : en
Pages : 42
Get Book Here
Book Description
Variable speed limit (VSL) systems have been used in a number of countries, particularly in Europe, as a method to improve flow and increase safety. VSLs use detectors to collect data on current traffic and/or weather conditions. Posted speed limits are then dynamically updated to reflect the conditions that motorists are actually experiencing. Presenting drivers with speed limits that are appropriate for current conditions may reduce speed variance, a concept sometimes called speed harmonization. If properly designed, VSL systems have been shown to reduce crash occurrence and can also reduce system travel time through increased uniformity in traffic speeds. High-volume urban work zones tend to be prone to congestion and safety problems, and VSLs may be one way to ameliorate these issues. VSLs were recently installed at a high-volume, congested urban work zone located on I-495 (the Capital Beltway, hereinafter the Beltway) between the Springfield Interchange in Springfield, Virginia, and the Virginia-Maryland state line on the Woodrow Wilson Memorial Bridge. VSL signs were activated in late July 2008, but initial evaluations of the system showed inconclusive effects. Changing site conditions made a direct before-and-after evaluation of the system deployed in the field problematic, and some problems with the control algorithm were also noted. Given the difficulties in evaluating the system deployed in the field, a calibrated simulation of the site was constructed to assess the effects of the VSL system on traffic operations and safety surrogate measures. The simulation platform also provided an opportunity to examine a number of system configurations to assess how changes in system design and driver behavior might affect a variety of measures. The results indicated that the VSL could create substantial improvements in traffic operations provided the demand did not exceed capacity by too large a margin. The location of the VSL signs played an important role in operational performance. The study recommends that the Virginia Department of Transportation continue to pursue this technology but carefully scrutinize algorithm design and VSL sign placement. Further, a cost/benefit analysis indicated that VSLs may be most appropriate for long-term applications.
Author: Cristina Dos Santos
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Automobile driving simulators
Languages : en
Pages : 406
Get Book Here
Book Description
Researchers at the University of Central Florida (UCF) have been working during the past few years on different strategies to improve freeway safety in real-time. An ongoing research at UCF has investigated crash patterns that occurred on a stretch of Interstate-4 located in Orlando, FL and created statistical models to predict in real-time the likelihood of a crash in terms of time and space. The models were then tested using PARAMICS micro-simulation and different strategies that would reduce the risk of crashes were suggested. One of the main recommended strategies was the use of Variable Speed Limits (VSL) which intervenes by reducing the speed upstream the segment of high risk and increasing the speed downstream. The purpose of this study is to examine the recommendations reached by the micro-simulation using the UCF driving simulator. Drivers' speed behavior in response to changes in speed limits and different information messages are observed. Different scenarios that represent the recommendations from the earlier micro-simulation study and three different messages displayed using Variable Message Signs (VMS) as an added measure to advice drivers about changes in the speed limit were created. In addition, abrupt and gradual changes in speed were tested against the scenarios that maintained the speed limit constant or did include a VSL or VMS in the scenarios' design (base case). Dynamic congestion was also added to the scenarios' design to observe drivers' reactions and speed reductions once drivers approached congestion. A total of 85 subjects were recruited. Gender and age were the controlling variables for the subjects' recruitment. Each of the subjects drove 3 out of a total of 24 scenarios. In addition, a survey was conducted and involved hypothetical questions, including knowledge about VMS and VSL, and questions about their driving behavior. The survey data were useful in identifying the subjects' compliance with the speed limit and VSL/VMS acceptance. Two statistical analytical techniques were performed on the data that were collected from the simulator: ANOVA and PROC MIXED. The ANOVA test was used to investigate if the differences in speed and reaction distances between subjects were statistically significant for each sign compared to the base case. The PROC MIXED analysis was used to investigate the differences of all scenarios (24x24) based on the spot speed data collected for each driver. It was found from the analyses that drivers follow better the message displayed on VMS that informs them that the speed is changing, whether it is or not, strictly enforced as opposed to providing the reason for change or no information. Moreover, an abrupt change in speed produced immediate results; however both abrupt and gradual changes in speed produced the same reduction in speed at the target zone. It was also noticed that most drivers usually drive 5 mph above the speed limit, even though in the survey analysis the majority of them stated that they drive in compliance with the speed limit or with the flow of traffic. This means that if a modest speed reduction of 5 mph is requested they will ignore it, but if a 10 mph reduction is recommended they will reduce the speed by at least 5 mph. Consequently, it was noticed that drivers arrived at the congestion zone with a slower speed than the base speed limit due to the combination of VMS and VSL signage. By having drivers approaching congestion with a slower speed, potential rear-end crashes could be avoided. Comparing the two genders indicated that females are more likely to follow the VMS's recommendations to reduce the speed. Also females in general drive above the speed limit between 2 mph and 3 mph, while males drive above the speed limit between 5 mph and 8 mph. From the analysis of the age factor, it was concluded that drivers from the 16-19 age group drive faster and drivers from the 45 and above age group drive slower, than the drivers from the other groups. In general, all drivers reduced and/or increased their speed accordingly when a VMS and/or VSL was present in the scenario advising for this change in the speed limit. The investigations conducted for this thesis proved that the recommendations suggested previously based on the crash risk model and micro-simulation (Abdel-Aty et al., 2006) aid drivers in reducing their speed before they approach a segment of high risk and by doing so reduce the likelihood of a crash. Finally, the real-time safety benefits of VMS and VSL should be continuously evaluated in future studies.
Author: Disapat Lavansiri
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Roads
Languages : en
Pages : 312
Get Book Here
Book Description
Author:
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Express highways
Languages : en
Pages :
Get Book Here
Book Description
The Variable Speed Limit (VSL) system on the I-4 corridor in Orlando was implemented by Florida Department of Transportation in 2008, and since its deployment, it was revealed that the majority of traffic exceeds the speed limit by more mph when the speed limit is reduced versus when it is at the baseline level. The overall objective of this project was to gain a better understanding of the drivers' perception of the I-4 VSL system, to evaluate operations along the VSL zone of the I-4, and to investigate VSL strategies that have the potential to improve operations along I-4. Focus group studies as well as in-vehicle observation studies were conducted to evaluate driver perceptions. Participants indicated they would typically not reduce their speeds unless the drivers/motorists in their surroundings reduce theirs, and they suggested installing the VSL sign boards on both the sides of the roadway and, if possible, on the overhead sign boards at each lane. Through a combination of sensor data analysis and aerial reconnaissance, the research team identified bottleneck locations and congestion times. Based on these, a CORSIM simulation of the I-4 VSL zone was built in order to evaluate various potential VSL algorithms and their respective settings.
Author: Emily C. Layton
Publisher:
ISBN: 9781124925202
Category : Variable speed limits
Languages : en
Pages : 114
Get Book Here
Book Description
Speed limits are generally created for ideal road conditions. When road conditions deteriorate, speed limits tend to become unreasonable, and enforcement of safe driving becomes difficult. Variable speed limit (VSL) systems are used to adjust speeds in accordance with the changing conditions in an attempt to reduce the variation of speeds among all vehicles. This research highlights the findings from the variable speed limit system in place along the Elk Mountain Corridor of I-80 in Southeastern Wyoming during the first and second full winter seasons of VSL implementation. Specifically this research focuses on speeds and variations of speed and the effect the VSL system has had on individual vehicles. The objective of this research was to determine if the VSL system was effective in reducing speeds and speed variation during adverse conditions. Further, this analysis attempts to determine the effect of the VSL system on driver behavior. The VSL system was effective at reducing speeds when properly implemented, reduced speed variation as well. Drivers respond differently to different levels of VSL implementation.
Author: Katie McCann
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Roads
Languages : en
Pages : 53
Get Book Here
Book Description
In Virginia, sections of I-77 and I-64 in mountainous parts of the state have significant recurring fog events. These locations have also been the sites of several chain reaction crashes involving more than 50 vehicles during fog. These crashes were typically caused by drivers traveling too fast for the visibility conditions. To improve safety on the I-77 corridor, the Virginia Department of Transportation constructed a variable speed limit (VSL) system that posts dynamic speed limits based on the visibility condition. As of April 2016, the system was undergoing pre-deployment testing. Before the system was activated, it was important to understand existing driver speed choice behavior during low visibility conditions. It was possible that posting a VSL speed based only on the stopping sight distance (SSD) could create significant speed variance and decrease safety if drivers were driving much faster than conditions would warrant. In this study, crash, speed, and visibility data were examined at several locations on I-64 and I-77 where there were recurring fog events. The crash history for I-77 revealed that crashes during low visibility conditions were more likely to be severe and involve more than two vehicles than crashes during clear conditions. Mean speed analysis found that observed mean speeds exceeded safe speeds for all low visibility conditions and at all sites. In the worst visibility conditions, drivers often exceeded the safe speed by more than 20 mph. Standard deviation analysis found that speed variance did not increase as visibility decreased on I-77, but for several locations on I-64, the standard deviation was different during low visibility when compared to clear conditions. Models were developed to allow a better understanding of the relationship between speed and visibility. The models showed that although motorists reduce their speeds in low visibility, there is still a significant differential between observed speeds and the safe speed calculated using the SSD. The models showed that speeds for I-64 were much less sensitive to changes in visibility compared to I-77. A possible explanation for this difference is the presence of illuminated in-pavement markers on I-64. The improved delineation provided by these markers during foggy conditions may cause drivers to perceive less of a need to reduce speed during limited visibility. It is also possible that mean speeds in low visibility conditions are higher on I-64 because of the regular commuters who may be more comfortable driving during foggy conditions. The observed driver behavior from this study is being used as a basis for the VSL control algorithm that is being implemented in the field. A primary concern of the operators of the VSL system is that it will not be heeded by all motorists and thus will result in increased speed variance in foggy conditions. The developed model was used to create a VSL control algorithm to help bridge the gap between current driver behavior and safe speed. It is recommended that future VSL system deployments reflect existing driver behavior in the initial algorithms as well. After VSL activation, speed and crash data for I-77 should be analyzed to determine the operational and safety effects of the system. If the system on I-77 reduces the frequency and severity of crashes, improves speed limit compliance, and reduces speed variance, a similar system should be developed for I-64 using the current driver behavior models from this study as part of the initial algorithm.
Author: Yanfei Sui
Publisher:
ISBN: 9781303737176
Category : Automobile driving in bad weather
Languages : en
Pages : 213
Get Book Here
Book Description
Speed, speed variation, and speed compliance are important factors related to both frequency and severity of traffic crashes. Decreasing the speed variation and increasing the driver compliance levels have been realized as effective methods to improve the traffic safety. Variable speed limits (VSL) systems along rural roadways are an operational strategy used to address speed related safety problems. VSL systems can aid drivers in selecting safe speeds for the current conditions, which is critical on Wyoming roadways where frequent and severe winter weather conditions often occur. To ensure that the VSL systems will be effective, the posted variable speeds need the highest degree of speed compliance from drivers in the corridor. The objective of this research is to determine the effects of the VSL system on driver's speed behavior on rural corridors and provide the guidance for further development of the VSL system in Wyoming. Results showed that the VSL systems were effective in reducing the speed and speed variation as well as increasing the driver compliance during the implementation period. However, drivers showed the different speed responses according to the various VSL implementation levels. Drivers showed a low tolerance for a large speed reduction on the VSL.
Author: Brian Joseph Schaefer
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Evolutionary programming (Computer science)
Languages : en
Pages : 182
Get Book Here
Book Description
"The variable speed limit (VSL) system has been adopted on more and more roadways across the globe as an engineering tool for controlling traffic flow, particularly during congestion situations. An important and fundamental question raised among traffic engineers is: Are the costs of installing and operating variable speed limits really justified? In order to answer this question, this thesis measures the effectiveness of the VSL system applying the VISSIM microscopic simulation model to a non-recurrent congestion situation. For the analysis, a section of interstate was modeled in VISSIM and calibrated so that the simulated results closely reproduce the observed data collected from traffic detectors. The calibration process is accomplished using a genetic algorithm (GA) programmed in MATLAB. Once the interstate system is calibrated to the static speed limit condition, the VSL system is portrayed on the model by temporarily blocking lanes to measure the effectiveness of VSL during an incident situation. Multiple incident locations and different VSL configurations are tested to investigate various possible forms of reality. The simulated results of with-VSL and without-VSL systems were compared and evaluated. The results show that no significant changes in travel times are observed, but queue lengths and fuel consumption decrease by 10-20% and 3-5% respectively. The speed variances upstream of the incidents also decreased 10-25% depending on location, which in the end may lead to fewer crashes. Before a VSL system is constructed a study should be conducted to determine if the cost of installing and maintaining the system is justified by the benefits. The benefits of a VSL system include a decrease in fuel consumption as well as a decrease in the deviation of speeds, potentially leading to a reduction in crashes. Further studies need to be done to determine exactly how much the number of crashes could potentially be reduced. If a governing authority has the means for a VSL system they could potentially be justified by a reduction in crashes on the roadway, but the breadth of this thesis does not have enough evidence to support the case that there will be a definite reduction in the number of crashes"--Abstract, leaf iii.
Author: Byungkyu Park
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Roads
Languages : en
Pages : 188
Get Book Here
Book Description
There has been a considerable increase in the amount of construction work on the U.S. national highways in recent years. This is a direct result of the current transportation policies emphasis on the maintenance of existing facilities rather than on building new ones. But with the increase in the amount of traffic on the interstates, the safety at the construction sites is getting worsened. Variable speed limit (VSL) systems are a kind of intelligent transportation systems (ITS) technology and they try to increase safety by posting the maximum or minimum speed limits. The speeds to be posted on the VSL signs are calculated manually or with the help of algorithms. This study is an attempt to evaluate the performance of various speeds at work zones and to develop VSL control logics that would calculate suitable speeds for different traffic conditions. The research is conducted by simulating a postulated test-bed network and then validating the results by simulating a real world work zone site. The study uses a microscopic simulation model - VISSIM. The study developed a safety surrogate measure, minimum safety distance equation (MSDE), to quantify safety. Travel times have primarily been used to quantify mobility. Since most of the existing VSL control logics consider only the traffic advisory speed or average traffic speed, an attempt was made to develop a logic that would consider both safety and mobility in calculating speeds. The results of simulating the postulated network indicated that the performance of speeds varied with traffic demand volumes and compliance rate conditions. In general an increase in speed decreased safety, but improved travel time. Surprisingly at low volume and low compliance conditions an increase in speed also improved safety. In order to find the speeds that provide optimal measures of safety and mobility a normalization procedure that combines travel time and safety measures is used. The performance of the logics is mixed. In general logic 3 (that considers both safety and mobility measures to calculate VSL speed) performed better than logics 1 and 2 (that use average traffic speed). However logics 1 and 2 performed better than Logic 3 for oversaturated conditions and for low volume and low compliance conditions. Statistical analysis was performed to substantiate the results of the base cases and the logics. The performance of the VSL system was also evaluated by simulating a real world work zone site at Covington, Virginia. The results were found to be consistent with those of the postulated network.
