Discretionary Justice

Discretionary Justice PDF Author: Kenneth Culp Davis
Publisher: LSU Press
ISBN: 0807156558
Category : History
Languages : en
Pages : 292

Get Book

Book Description
Research about justice for individual parties has been primarily concerned with the content of rules and principles and has insufficiently tried to penetrate discretionary justice as meted out by police, prosecutors, and other administrators. In this groundbreaking study Kenneth Culp Davis dispels the prevailing notion that discretionary justice is too elusive for scholarly investigation. Davis advances proposals for badly needed reforms in our system of discretionary justice and lays the groundwork for further empirical and philosophical studies. "Our jurisprudence of statutes and of judge-made law," says Davis, "is overdeveloped; our jurisprudence of administrative justice, of police justice, of prosecutor justice- of discretionary justice is under-developed. We need a new jurisprudence that will encompass all of justice, not just the easy half of it.

Discretionary Justice

Discretionary Justice PDF Author: Kenneth Culp Davis
Publisher: LSU Press
ISBN: 0807156558
Category : History
Languages : en
Pages : 292

Get Book

Book Description
Research about justice for individual parties has been primarily concerned with the content of rules and principles and has insufficiently tried to penetrate discretionary justice as meted out by police, prosecutors, and other administrators. In this groundbreaking study Kenneth Culp Davis dispels the prevailing notion that discretionary justice is too elusive for scholarly investigation. Davis advances proposals for badly needed reforms in our system of discretionary justice and lays the groundwork for further empirical and philosophical studies. "Our jurisprudence of statutes and of judge-made law," says Davis, "is overdeveloped; our jurisprudence of administrative justice, of police justice, of prosecutor justice- of discretionary justice is under-developed. We need a new jurisprudence that will encompass all of justice, not just the easy half of it.

Discretionary Justice in Europe and America

Discretionary Justice in Europe and America PDF Author: Kenneth Culp Davis
Publisher: Urbana : University of Illinois Press
ISBN:
Category : Law
Languages : en
Pages : 224

Get Book

Book Description


Discretionary Justice

Discretionary Justice PDF Author: Howard Abadinsky
Publisher: Charles C. Thomas Publisher
ISBN:
Category : Law
Languages : en
Pages : 206

Get Book

Book Description


Discretionary Justice

Discretionary Justice PDF Author: Kenneth Culp Davis
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Administrative discretion
Languages : en
Pages : 6

Get Book

Book Description


Discretionary Justice

Discretionary Justice PDF Author: Carolyn Strange
Publisher: NYU Press
ISBN: 1479810908
Category : Law
Languages : en
Pages : 336

Get Book

Book Description
The pardon is an act of mercy, tied to the divine right of kings. Why did New York retain this mode of discretionary justice after the Revolution? And how did governors’ use of this prerogative change with the advent of the penitentiary and the introduction of parole? This book answers these questions by mining previously unexplored evidence held in official pardon registers, clemency files, prisoner aid association reports and parole records. This is the first book to analyze the histories of mercy and parole through the same lens, as related but distinct forms of discretionary decision-making. It draws on governors’ public papers and private correspondence to probe their approach to clemency, and it uses qualitative and quantitative methods to profile petitions for mercy, highlighting controversial cases that stirred public debate. Political pressure to render the use of discretion more certain and less personal grew stronger over the nineteenth century, peaking during constitutional conventionsand reaching its height in the Progressive Era. Yet, New York’s legislators left the power to pardon in the governor’s hands, where it remains today. Unlike previous works that portray parole as the successor to the pardon, this book shows that reliance upon and faith in discretion has proven remarkably resilient, even in the state that led the world toward penal modernity.

The Invisible Justice System

The Invisible Justice System PDF Author: Burton Atkins
Publisher: Anderson Publishing Company (OH)
ISBN:
Category : Law
Languages : en
Pages : 432

Get Book

Book Description
This anthology presents articles on various aspects of discretionary decisionmaking in the administration of justice. Discretionary justice suggests latitude of decisionmaking rather than formality or certainty, and unlike the symbolic idea of due process, it suggests that idiosyncrasy rather than rules may guide decisionmaking within the administration of criminal justice at all levels of the police, court, and penal systems. The relationship between forms of discretion and the criminal justice system is explored. The role of discretion at the arrest, prosecution, and sentencing levels as well as within the framework of correctional institutions is examined. The development of the discretionary ethic is discussed, and the severity and legality of its application in criminal justice procedures are examined. Discretion on the part of the police is covered, with special attention to legal norms and discretion in the police sentencing processes, factors in police discretion and decisionmaking, and administrative problems in controlling the exercise of police authority. An approach to the legal control of police in terms of discretionary powers is presented. The role of prosecutorial discretion is underscored; the application of discretion during charging and plea bargaining processes is examined, and means for controlling prosecutorial discretion are discussed. Judicial discretion during sentencing is also examined, with attention to pretrial decisionmaking, the growth and consequences of sentencing discretion, and contemporary sentencing proposals. Finally, the application of discretionary powers within the prison environment is summarized; decisionmaking within the prison community, the control of discretionary powers of prison organizations, the use of discretion in determining the severity of punishment for incarcerated offenders, and discretion within the parole bureaucracies decisionmaking process are discussed.

Discretionary Justice

Discretionary Justice PDF Author: Carolyn Strange
Publisher: NYU Press
ISBN: 1479899925
Category : Law
Languages : en
Pages : 333

Get Book

Book Description
The pardon is an act of mercy, tied to the divine right of kings. Why did New York retain this mode of discretionary justice after the Revolution? And how did governors’ use of this prerogative change with the advent of the penitentiary and the introduction of parole? This book answers these questions by mining previously unexplored evidence held in official pardon registers, clemency files, prisoner aid association reports and parole records. This is the first book to analyze the histories of mercy and parole through the same lens, as related but distinct forms of discretionary decision-making. It draws on governors’ public papers and private correspondence to probe their approach to clemency, and it uses qualitative and quantitative methods to profile petitions for mercy, highlighting controversial cases that stirred public debate. Political pressure to render the use of discretion more certain and less personal grew stronger over the nineteenth century, peaking during constitutional conventionsand reaching its height in the Progressive Era. Yet, New York’s legislators left the power to pardon in the governor’s hands, where it remains today. Unlike previous works that portray parole as the successor to the pardon, this book shows that reliance upon and faith in discretion has proven remarkably resilient, even in the state that led the world toward penal modernity.

Discretionary Justice

Discretionary Justice PDF Author: Paul E. Dow
Publisher:
ISBN:
Category : Law
Languages : en
Pages : 320

Get Book

Book Description


Discretionary Justice

Discretionary Justice PDF Author: Leslie Paik
Publisher: Rutgers University Press
ISBN: 0813550068
Category : Law
Languages : en
Pages : 241

Get Book

Book Description
Juvenile drug courts are on the rise in the United States, as a result of a favorable political climate and justice officials' endorsement of the therapeutic jurisprudence movement--the concept of combining therapeutic care with correctional discipline. The goal is to divert nonviolent youth drug offenders into addiction treatment instead of long-term incarceration. Discretionary Justice overviews the system, taking readers behind the scenes of the juvenile drug court. Based on fifteen months of ethnographic fieldwork and interviews at a California court, Leslie Paik explores the staff's decision-making practices in assessing the youths' cases, concentrating on the way accountability and noncompliance are assessed. Using the concept of "workability," Paik demonstrates how compliance, and what is seen by staff as "noncompliance," are the constructed results of staff decisions, fluctuating budgets, and sometimes questionable drug test results. While these courts largely focus on holding youths responsible for their actions, this book underscores the social factors that shape how staff members view progress in the court. Paik also emphasizes the perspectives of children and parents. Given the growing emphasis on individual responsibility in other settings, such as schools and public welfare agencies, Paik's findings are relevant outside the juvenile justice system.

Taming the System

Taming the System PDF Author: Samuel Walker
Publisher: Oxford University Press, USA
ISBN: 0195078209
Category : History
Languages : en
Pages : 202

Get Book

Book Description
Traces the history of attempts since the 1950s to control the discretionary powers in the US criminal justice system. The author synthesizes the findings of a large body of literature for the benefit of practitioners and interested students of the criminal justice system.