Countering Polarization

Countering Polarization PDF Author: Charles Notess
Publisher:
ISBN: 9781436314664
Category : Reconciliation
Languages : en
Pages : 0

Get Book Here

Book Description
In concluding my book, I emphasize the need for changes in the cultural values of citizens around the world. These changes include truly independent judicial systems that are founded upon the universal values of compassion toward all others and actions that emphasize fairness and equality of opportunity to live a good life. This implies replacing the tribal-scale systems of honor with larger-scale trusted systems of justice organized at state, national, and global scales. It is the clan and tribal systems of honor that often lead to violence, torture of others, and nepotism. The foregoing considerations apply to peacemaking in the Middle East, in other third world nations, and in Western industrial nations, including America. Closed minds and tribal (small) scale commitments are found in all of these areas. Limited influence, power, and frustration at not knowing how to negotiate peaceably with ones oppressors and exploiters who are in power often lead to violent responses. Such responses are found in street gangs, rebellious outcasts from society with little hope in their future, regressive believers of orthodox religious and/or political beliefs, and the like. Updating political and religious traditions to make them more relevant will not be easy. I believe that some kind of independent and trustworthy judicial hierarchy guided by universal moral principles is needed to provide checks and balances for the narrow perspectives that sometimes dominate religious, political and corporate organizations. Poorly educated leaders in third world countries mislead their people, especially those with little or no education. They mislead them to use religious justifications to support evil actions. Somewhat similar problems arise among Christian believers wherein clerics follow a selective literalist approach to theology, one that is often slanted by extremist political tactics. When political perspectives dominate the religious ones, tactics such as single-issue politics can take over, especially before elections. It is important to separate the tribal aspects of traditional cultures from the basic human values that are propagated by the main world religions. The intent of the basic and universal political and religious values can be maintained as the old cultural traditions are changed. The counseling and teaching of young persons and adults must include providing road maps that help each person navigate their own paths of life. Such navigation requires commitment to ever-increasing scales of perspective taking and community, and climbing their own path toward transcendent perspectives and relations to transcendent powers while maintaining a balance between commitments to personal development and community development. Development of strong personal identities requires extending compassion to others and serving the welfare of diverse others. Emotional energy should be channeled toward helping, nurturing and caring for others, not by dominating their lives, but by training and teaching for self-sufficiency within supportive communities. Non-Governmental Organizations (NGO's) provide many opportunities for serving communities in positive and constructive ways. Religious leaders need to learn how to build a sacred set of memories and stories about persons with good characters that their followers will internalize to some extent. Sacred symbols can be in the forms of songs and poetry, but they should not sacralize violent acts from the past, which often serves to perpetuate hatred, or lead to the idea that one's group is a chosen people. Marc Gopin made these latter points in his book "Between Eden and Armageddon". Immigrants can follow paths to: assimilation, reorientation (rather than regression), and some mix of assimilation and reorientation. How much of the culture does one change through assimilation? What parts of the culture should be de-em

Countering Polarization

Countering Polarization PDF Author: Charles Notess
Publisher:
ISBN: 9781436314664
Category : Reconciliation
Languages : en
Pages : 0

Get Book Here

Book Description
In concluding my book, I emphasize the need for changes in the cultural values of citizens around the world. These changes include truly independent judicial systems that are founded upon the universal values of compassion toward all others and actions that emphasize fairness and equality of opportunity to live a good life. This implies replacing the tribal-scale systems of honor with larger-scale trusted systems of justice organized at state, national, and global scales. It is the clan and tribal systems of honor that often lead to violence, torture of others, and nepotism. The foregoing considerations apply to peacemaking in the Middle East, in other third world nations, and in Western industrial nations, including America. Closed minds and tribal (small) scale commitments are found in all of these areas. Limited influence, power, and frustration at not knowing how to negotiate peaceably with ones oppressors and exploiters who are in power often lead to violent responses. Such responses are found in street gangs, rebellious outcasts from society with little hope in their future, regressive believers of orthodox religious and/or political beliefs, and the like. Updating political and religious traditions to make them more relevant will not be easy. I believe that some kind of independent and trustworthy judicial hierarchy guided by universal moral principles is needed to provide checks and balances for the narrow perspectives that sometimes dominate religious, political and corporate organizations. Poorly educated leaders in third world countries mislead their people, especially those with little or no education. They mislead them to use religious justifications to support evil actions. Somewhat similar problems arise among Christian believers wherein clerics follow a selective literalist approach to theology, one that is often slanted by extremist political tactics. When political perspectives dominate the religious ones, tactics such as single-issue politics can take over, especially before elections. It is important to separate the tribal aspects of traditional cultures from the basic human values that are propagated by the main world religions. The intent of the basic and universal political and religious values can be maintained as the old cultural traditions are changed. The counseling and teaching of young persons and adults must include providing road maps that help each person navigate their own paths of life. Such navigation requires commitment to ever-increasing scales of perspective taking and community, and climbing their own path toward transcendent perspectives and relations to transcendent powers while maintaining a balance between commitments to personal development and community development. Development of strong personal identities requires extending compassion to others and serving the welfare of diverse others. Emotional energy should be channeled toward helping, nurturing and caring for others, not by dominating their lives, but by training and teaching for self-sufficiency within supportive communities. Non-Governmental Organizations (NGO's) provide many opportunities for serving communities in positive and constructive ways. Religious leaders need to learn how to build a sacred set of memories and stories about persons with good characters that their followers will internalize to some extent. Sacred symbols can be in the forms of songs and poetry, but they should not sacralize violent acts from the past, which often serves to perpetuate hatred, or lead to the idea that one's group is a chosen people. Marc Gopin made these latter points in his book "Between Eden and Armageddon". Immigrants can follow paths to: assimilation, reorientation (rather than regression), and some mix of assimilation and reorientation. How much of the culture does one change through assimilation? What parts of the culture should be de-em

Political Polarization in American Politics

Political Polarization in American Politics PDF Author: John Sides
Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing USA
ISBN: 1501306278
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 193

Get Book Here

Book Description
Political Polarization in American Politics provides short, accessible chapters about the nature and extent of political polarization within the American public and in American political institutions. These chapters capture the central ideas and debates in political science research on polarization, and are written by leading scholars in this subfield. Each chapter is accompanied by discussion questions and a guide to further reading, making this a great addition to any course looking at issues of polarization.

Solutions to Political Polarization in America

Solutions to Political Polarization in America PDF Author: Nathaniel Persily
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
ISBN: 1107087112
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 317

Get Book Here

Book Description
This volume assembles several top analysts of American politics to focus on solutions to polarization.

Compromise in an Age of Party Polarization

Compromise in an Age of Party Polarization PDF Author: Jennifer Wolak
Publisher: Oxford University Press
ISBN: 0197510523
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 233

Get Book Here

Book Description
Congressional debates are increasingly defined by gridlock and stalemate, with partisan showdowns that lead to government shutdowns. Compromise in Congress seems hard to reach, but do politicians deserve all the blame? Legislators who refuse to compromise might be doing just what their constituents want them to do. In Compromise in an Age of Party Polarization, Jennifer Wolak challenges this wisdom and demonstrates that Americans value compromise in politics. Citizens want more from elected officials than just ideological representation--they also care about the processes by which disagreements are settled. Using evidence from a variety of surveys and innovative experiments, she shows the persistence of people's support for compromise across a range of settings-even when it comes at the cost of partisan goals and policy objectives. While polarization levels are high in contemporary America, our partisan demands are checked by our principled views of how we believe politics should be practiced. By underscoring this basic yet mostly ignored fact, this book stands as an important first step toward trying to reduce the extreme polarization that plagues our politics.

Democracies Divided

Democracies Divided PDF Author: Thomas Carothers
Publisher: Brookings Institution Press
ISBN: 081573722X
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 321

Get Book Here

Book Description
“A must-read for anyone concerned about the fate of contemporary democracies.”—Steven Levitsky, co-author of How Democracies Die 2020 CHOICE Outstanding Academic Title Why divisions have deepened and what can be done to heal them As one part of the global democratic recession, severe political polarization is increasingly afflicting old and new democracies alike, producing the erosion of democratic norms and rising societal anger. This volume is the first book-length comparative analysis of this troubling global phenomenon, offering in-depth case studies of countries as wide-ranging and important as Brazil, India, Kenya, Poland, Turkey, and the United States. The case study authors are a diverse group of country and regional experts, each with deep local knowledge and experience. Democracies Divided identifies and examines the fissures that are dividing societies and the factors bringing polarization to a boil. In nearly every case under study, political entrepreneurs have exploited and exacerbated long-simmering divisions for their own purposes—in the process undermining the prospects for democratic consensus and productive governance. But this book is not simply a diagnosis of what has gone wrong. Each case study discusses actions that concerned citizens and organizations are taking to counter polarizing forces, whether through reforms to political parties, institutions, or the media. The book’s editors distill from the case studies a range of possible ways for restoring consensus and defeating polarization in the world’s democracies. Timely, rigorous, and accessible, this book is of compelling interest to civic activists, political actors, scholars, and ordinary citizens in societies beset by increasingly rancorous partisanship.

Polarized Politics and Policy Consequences

Polarized Politics and Policy Consequences PDF Author: Diana Epstein
Publisher: Rand Corporation
ISBN: 0833042203
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 46

Get Book Here

Book Description
To elucidate the impact of polarization on the daily lives of U.S. citizens, the research community may need to modify its benchmarks for what constitutes a successful public policy. The authors suggest that we need a better understanding of how polarization affects the quantity and substance of rulemaking, regulations, and judicial decisions. We also need to examine the effects of partisan polarization at the state and local levels of government, how much polarization complicates the conduct of defense and foreign policy, and precisely how polarization affects different policy areas. The publication should be of interest to members of Congress, presidential candidates, civil servants, political scientists, reporters, and stakeholders seeking to influence public policy.

American Gridlock

American Gridlock PDF Author: James A. Thurber
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
ISBN: 1107114160
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 435

Get Book Here

Book Description
American Gridlock is a comprehensive analysis of polarization encompassing national and state politics, voters, elites, activists, the media, and the three branches of government.

Red and Blue Nation?

Red and Blue Nation? PDF Author: Pietro S. Nivola
Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield
ISBN: 0815760787
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 336

Get Book Here

Book Description
A Brookings Institution Press and the Hoover Institution publication America's polarized politics are largely disconnected from mainstream public preferences. This disconnect poses fundamental dangers for the representativeness and accountability of government, as well as the already withering public trust in it. As the 2008 presidential race kicks into gear, the political climate certainly will not become less polarized. With important issues to address—including immigration policy, health care, and the funding of the Iraq war—it is critical that essential policies not be hostage to partisan political battles. Building upon the findings of the first volume of Red and Blue Nation? (Brookings, 2006), which explored the extent of political polarization and its potential causes, this new volume delves into the consequences of the gulf between "red states" and "blue states." The authors examine the impact of these political divisions on voter behavior, Congressional law-making, judicial selection, and foreign policy formation. They shed light on hotly debated institutional reform proposals—including changes to the electoral system and the congressional rules of engagement—and ultimately present research-supported policies and reforms for alleviating the underlying causes of political polarization. While most discussion of polarization takes place in separate spheres of journalism and academia, Red and Blue Nation? brings together a unique set of voices with a wide variety of perspectives to enrich our understanding of the issue. Written in a broad, accessible style, it is a resource for anyone interested in the future of electoral politics in America. Contributors include Marc Hetherington and John G. Geer (Vanderbilt University), Deborah Jordan Brooks (Dartmouth College), Martin P. Wattenberg (University of California, Irvine), Barbara Sinclair and Joel D. Aberbach (UCLA), Christopher H. Foreman (University of Maryland), Keith Krehbiel (Stanford University), Sarah A. Binder, Benjamin Wittes, Jonathan Rauch, and William A. Ga

Polarization

Polarization PDF Author: Nolan McCarty
Publisher: Oxford University Press
ISBN: 0190867795
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 176

Get Book Here

Book Description
The 2016 election of Donald J. Trump invoked a time for reflection about the state of American politics and its deep ideological, cultural, racial, regional, and economic divisions. But one aspect that the contemporary discussions often miss is that these fissures have been opening over several decades and are deeply rooted in the structure of American politics and society. In Polarization: What Everyone Needs to Know® Nolan McCarty takes readers through what scholars know and don't know about the origins, development, and implications of our rising political conflicts, delving into social, economic, and geographic determinants of polarization in the United States. While the current political climate seems to suggest that extreme views are becoming more popular, McCarty also argues that, contrary to popular belief, the 2016 election was a natural outgrowth of 40 years of polarized politics, rather than a significant break with the past. He evaluates arguments over which factors that have created this state of affairs, including gerrymandered legislative districts, partisan primary nomination systems, and our private campaign finance system. He also considers the potential of major reforms such as instating proportional representation or ranked choice voting to remedy extreme polarization. A concise overview of a complex and crucial topic in US politics, this book is for anyone wanting to understand how to repair the cracks in our system.

Polarized

Polarized PDF Author: James E. Campbell
Publisher: Princeton University Press
ISBN: 1400889278
Category : Political Science
Languages : en
Pages : 345

Get Book Here

Book Description
An eye-opening look at how and why America has become so politically polarized Many continue to believe that the United States is a nation of political moderates. In fact, it is a nation divided. It has been so for some time and has grown more so. This book provides a new and historically grounded perspective on the polarization of America, systematically documenting how and why it happened. Polarized presents commonsense benchmarks to measure polarization, draws data from a wide range of historical sources, and carefully assesses the quality of the evidence. Through an innovative and insightful use of circumstantial evidence, it provides a much-needed reality check to claims about polarization. This rigorous yet engaging and accessible book examines how polarization displaced pluralism and how this affected American democracy and civil society. Polarized challenges the widely held belief that polarization is the product of party and media elites, revealing instead how the American public in the 1960s set in motion the increase of polarization. American politics became highly polarized from the bottom up, not the top down, and this began much earlier than often thought. The Democrats and the Republicans are now ideologically distant from each other and about equally distant from the political center. Polarized also explains why the parties are polarized at all, despite their battle for the decisive median voter. No subject is more central to understanding American politics than political polarization, and no other book offers a more in-depth and comprehensive analysis of the subject than this one.